Absence Ladder
The Absence Ladder is the order in which a canary the Proof Witness did not observe is classified, Blind, then Void, then Null, so that a missing observation is never counted as a stopped attack until the reason it is missing is known.
The three rungs
| Rung | Condition | Scores? |
|---|---|---|
| Blind | The canary’s Effect Point or effect type is outside the Witness Coverage Map. | No. The witness was not looking. |
| Void | Inside the map, but a black hole window covers the release, the landing or the witness. | No. The witness was looking; the thing it watched was gone. |
| Null | Inside the map, path live, no effect observed. | Yes. A dead canary: Stopped for a bad canary, False block for a good one. |
Why it exists
Silence is the most flattering result a broken test can produce. A witness that was not watching and a control that stopped everything look identical. The ladder forces the question “why was nothing seen?” to be answered before any credit is given.
The rules
- Blind is checked before Void, and Void before Null.
- A canary is never scored Stopped or False block unless its non-observation is Null.
- The Blind share and Void share are published beside every rate they would otherwise inflate. A rate without them is non-conforming.
- A Blind canary is a defect in the Mine Plan or the coverage map, not in the control, and is recorded as a finding of kind
blind.